Blog

  • Coastal Command

    Coastal Command

    On this day in 1945, 4 June, Coastal Command ended the longest war campaign of any RAF Command. Coastal Command (‘CC’) arguably failed to receive the attention and recognition it deserved for its crucial role in keeping open Britain’s sea lanes from the world; a 24-hour mission across an empty ocean is less glamorous than dropping a bomb on Berlin. But was arguably more important.

    It is difficult to be precise about when the very first ‘offensive’ patrol was undertaken. Air Commodore Graham Pitchfork writes in ‘RAF Day by Day’ that the first war action is noted as having taken place 24 August 1939, when 48 Squadron’s Avro Ansons started patrols over the North Sea – 10 days before Britain declared war and, indeed, 8 days before the German invasion of Poland, which started the war. But 48 Squadron’s Operations Record Book states, for example, that on 11 February 1939 it was tasked with locating a German tanker and submarine and on 20 March it located and photographed the German fleet in the North Sea.

    Short Sunderland GR.V, ML778/NS-Z, captained by Wing Commander J Barrett, the Commanding Officer of 201 Squadron and his crew, based at Castle Archdale, County Fermanagh, undertaking Coastal Command's last operational patrol of the war, escorting an Atlantic convoy south-west of Ireland. After taking off from the Northern Irish base at 1643 hours on 3 June, the aircraft set course to intercept convoy HX358 which consisted of 51 vessels, locating them at 2121 hours. The aircraft remained on station until midnight when the order "CEASE PATROL!" was received, and alighted on Lough Erne at 0321 hours to end Coastal Command's operational effort during the Battle of the Atlantic.Sunderland concludes last-ever war mission. Note additional fixed machine guns under nose turret. (Crown copyright. Ministry of Defence CH 15302)

    After taking off from the Northern Irish base at 1643 hours on 3 June, the aircraft set course to intercept convoy HX358 which consisted of 51 vessels, locating them at 2121 hours. The aircraft remained on station until midnight when the order “CEASE PATROL!” was received, and alighted on Lough Erne at 0321 hours to end Coastal Command’s operational effort during the Battle of ther Atlantic.

    The last war patrol ended at 0001 hrs. on 4 June 1945, 27 days after the German forces had formally surrendered. Although Grandadmiral Karl Dönitz, (whom Hitler nominated as German President before his suicide) had ordered all U-Boats to surrender, by surfacing and displaying a large black flag, the Royal Navy and CC were taking no chances; some U-Boats might genuinely not receive the order but there was also the fear that some might refuse to comply. This very last European combat flight was operated by Short Sunderland serial ML 778, coded NS.Z, (Captain, Wing Commander J Barrett) from No. 201 Squadron RAF, based at Castle Archdale, County Fermanagh.

    Coastal Command Resources

    In September 1939, all RAF resources (and indeed Naval and army) were wholly inadequate to the challenges ahead, but none more so than Coastal Command. Their primary task was the patrolling of inshore waters and protection of convoys: merchant shipping was placed under Admiralty control on 26 August 1939, and the first convoy sailed on 2 September.

    The available aircraft were woefully inadequate in both numbers and capability. On 1 September, Coastal Command’s Order of Battle listed 14 squadrons at 15 British bases and the following front-line aircraft:

    • Avro Anson 301
    • Lockheed Hudson 53
    • Vickers Vildebeest 30
    • Short Sunderland 27
    • Saro London 17
    • Supermarine Stranraer 9

    But the Order of Battle also shows only 163 actually serviceable.

    Supermarine Stranraer (RAF Museum P014425)

    Supermarine Stranraer (RAF Museum P014425)

    The Submarine Threat

    The only thing that really frightened me was the U-boat peril.
    Prime Minister Winston Churchill in his memoirs

    The aeroplane can no more eliminate the submarine
    than the crow can fight a mole.
    Admiral Karl Dönitz, Commander U-Boats, August 1942

    Britain is a small, densely populated, island wholly dependent on maritime trade to import the food and raw materials needed by a complex industrial economy, especially its war industries. During the Great War [First World War], German submarines (U-Boats from the German Unterseeboot) had a policy of unrestricted attacks on shipping, Allied and neutral – a ‘sink on sight’ policy – which in 1916-17 came very close to starving Britain into surrender. The Admiralty fully expected a repeat, should war break out in 1939, a belief made real.

    Britain declared war on Germany at 11.00 on 3 September 1939; just 8 hours and 39 minutes later, the liner SS Athenia was torpedoed off the Irish coast with major loss of life (passengers and crew). So the U-Boats were already out there and waiting. And during the dark days of 1942-43, they came close to achieving what they had failed to do in 1917. U-Boats were sinking Allied merchant ships faster than shipyards could replace them: the blackest month was May 1943, with sinkings of 120 ships totalling 693,000 tons.

    Just as in the night skies over Germany, CC’s war was as much technological and electronic as Bomber Command’s: a constant leap-frogging of offence and defence. From 1939 to mid 1943, U-boats were in the ascendant; CC dominated from then until early 1945 when the Kriegsmarine introduced a new technology which revolutionised submarine warfare.

    During the war, and perhaps even today, most people measured the success of Coastal Command by the number of submarines destroyed: but that was based upon a false assumption – that destroying the boats was the most important activity. In fact, as stated in the ‘Western Approaches Tactical Policy’, issued in April 1943 by Admiral Max Horton, Commander-in-Chief of Western Approaches, the primary military objective for both Royal Navy and Royal Air Force was ‘the safe and timely arrival of the convoy’.

    Submarine Technology

    Today’s nuclear-powered submarines – uncomfortable and cramped as they unarguably are – represent a far, far cry from those used in by both sides in the Second World War. Today, the boats [submarines are traditionally called ‘boats’] are fast and can remain submerged for literally months. Top speed of a nuclear boat is highly classified but even in the 1970s, speeds in excess of 35 knots (40 mph, 64 kph) were published. And the Royal Navy has just [May 2025] set a record with a Vanguard class Trident missile-carrying boat remaining submerged for 204 days without once breaking surface.

    By contrast, submarines of the war could proceed on the surface at the speed of a man bicycling but under water, barely at walking pace. And they relied on massive batteries driving electric motors for under-water propulsion, batteries which needed charging every 24 hours by surfacing and generating electricity from the diesel engines used for surface propulsion.

    Submerging for much longer than 24 hours risked killing the entire crew from oxygen starvation or carbon monoxide poisoning in a boat whose batteries were exhausted. Until a German invention which radically tilted the scales back in favour of the submarine: the Schnorchel – a pipe raised above the surface drawing in air and discharging exhaust fumes, enabling a submarine to recharge its batteries whilst remaining submerged and travelling underwater at close to the same speed as on the surface.

    The radar of the time could not detect a Schnorchel so the boats had again become invisible. Fortunately, by the time this technology could be produced at scale, Allied armies were moving into Germany and the war was nearly over: had this technology been widely deployed in 1943, the war might have ended very differently.

    Submarine Tactics

    Admiral Dönitz, overall U-Boat fleet commander, developed a strategy to form his U-Boats into Wolf Packs, a concentration of boats around a single convoy at a time. This involved setting a line of U-Boats across a convoy route with the first to spot it shadowing the convoy and calling in reinforcements by wireless, aided sometimes by reconnaissance flights by a Focke Wulf Fw 200 Condor/Kurier land-based aircraft. But given its very limited underwater speed, a shadowing submarine had to remain on the surface so if forced to dive by any aircraft circling the convoy, even if the aircraft did not spot the submarine, it could not match the convoy’s speed, thus allowing the convoy to escape. On that basis, even unarmed Tiger Moths patrolled the North Sea in the Autumn and Winter of 1939.

    How to find a submarine

    How do you find a U-Boat, a tiny speck in a vast ocean?

    Initially, the Mk. 1 Eyeball and a pair of Zeiss binoculars. Not much good by day and useless by night. Then introduce ASV [Anti Surface Vessel] radar. In daylight, accurate enough to find the target visually, again not much use by night as insufficiently accurate for an attack. Then add a Leigh Light – a massive searchlight on the aircraft. Find the submarine by radar then, when a mile or so away, point the searchlight at the radar target, switch on and hopefully a very startled U-Boat is seen on the surface, charging its batteries.

    Consolidated Catalina 210 Squadron. Note Leigh Light under starboard wing and radar aerials on both aircraft (RAF Museum P 011892)Consolidated Catalina 210 Squadron.
    Note Leigh Light under starboard wing and radar aerials on both aircraft (RAF Museum P 011892)

    Once underwater, one can only roughly estimate its position. Surface warships were equipped with ASDIC. This device – derived from the acronym for Anti Submarine Detection Investigation Committee and now called Sonar – was in effect underwater radar using sound rather than electric pulses – the ‘pings’ heard on war films when hunting submarines. But the ASDIC transmitter and receiver both had to be under water so a new device, a sonobuoy, was developed.

    Dropped by an aircraft, it too located the U-Boat by sound and transmitted its position back to the circling aircraft. A final device introduced on a very limited basis was MAD – Magnetic Anomaly Detection. The metal hull of the boat slightly distorted the Earth’s natural magnetic fields, a distortion which can be measured. United States Navy Catalinas operating under CC command at Gibraltar are known to have used MAD but this author has not seen any references to RAF aircraft being so equipped.

    Leigh Light. This one retracts into belly of Wellington aft of bomb bay. (RAF Museum London)Leigh Light. This one retracts into belly of Wellington aft of bomb bay.
    (RAF Museum London)

    Other electronics also helped detect the U-Boats, which had to send sighting reports back to headquarters in Lorient, France, when shadowing a convoy, as well as routine weather and fuel reports. To which Allied ships and aircraft were listening and by taking cross bearings using ‘Huff Duff’ [High Frequency aerials], could locate the boats.

    At the same time, Kriegsmarine headquarters were transmitting orders to the U-Boats which were intercepted and decrypted by Bletchley Park, so CC knew where the Wolf Pack would be assembling and hence define the search area more tightly. This decryption was aided in no small measure by the Royal Navy having captured a U-Boat in May 1941 and seized its crucial Enigma machine and related code books.

    Attack Methods and Weapons

    Given the importance of aircraft over a convoy, the critical performance criterion of an anti-submarine aircraft was range. The North Atlantic is vast: a typical convoy route from Liverpool to Halifax, Nova Scotia, had to cover 2,500 nautical miles.

    The best that CC had in 1939 was the Sunderland with a nominal range of 1,000 miles but that allowed no margin for weather nor time over the convoy. CC began to re-equip with modified bomber types (Whitley, Wellington, Halifax, occasional Fortress but never Lancasters, all much to the chagrin of Air Marshal Harris, who wanted every bomber built to be given to Bomber Command to destroy the German cities where submarines were constructed) but even after CC bases were established in Northern Ireland, Shetland Islands, Iceland, Faroes, Azores and Ascension, and including RCAF from Nova Scotia, Labrador and latterly Greenland, there was still a ‘Mid Atlantic Gap’ where U-Boats could lurk, safe, unless the convoy was important enough to be allotted an RN escort carrier or MAC (Merchant Aircraft Carrier).

    Mid Atlantic Gap – beyond air cover (RAF 1939 – 1945 Official History Vol. 2 'The Fight Avails' – see Bibliography)Mid Atlantic Gap – beyond air cover
    (RAF 1939 – 1945 Official History Vol. 2 ‘The Fight Avails’ – see Bibliography)

    The Gap was finally closed by two excellent products of the Consolidated Aircraft Corporation: the VLR [Very Long Range] Liberator and Catalina, the former with a range of up to 2,400 miles and the latter, capable of flying for 27 hours, a range of 2,500 miles. Patrols of up to 24 hours appear to have been routine.

    Operations Room wall plot at Headquarters Coastal Command RAF Northwood (RAF Museum AL00170)

    Operations Room wall plot at Headquarters Coastal Command RAF Northwood
    (RAF Museum AL00170)

    Having located a U-Boat, how to destroy it?

    During the Second World War, the primary air-launched anti-submarine weapon was the depth charge. Exploding under water, if near enough to the submarine (preferably within 50 yards), the shock wave would cause major internal damage and start leaks, even if it did not rupture the submarine’s pressure hull. But to be effective, the attacking aircraft should ideally fly at 45 degrees to the submarine’s track, and at low level for accuracy, to achieve a “straddle” – depth charges dropped each side of the boat.

    As the war progressed, a more effective air-launched weapon was the homing torpedo. This tracked the sounds caused by the boats’ propeller cavitating in the water – and a submarine cannot stop moving underwater or it would lose control over depth.

    Sunderland Depth ChargesSunderland depth charges (RAF Museum London)

    The Magnetic Anomaly Detector created more technical problems. A conventional bomb sight looks forward but the MAD can only say when it is directly over the submarine: any weapon dropped at that point would describe an arc down to the water, the impact distance ahead of the release point being in tens or hundreds of yards depending upon the speed and altitude at which launched.

    So a new device was invented – the reverse-firing bomb. At the moment of maximum MAD signal, the weapons would fire backwards at exactly the forward speed of the aircraft so would fall vertically. One of many electronic and technological advances during the latter half of the conflict.

    8. Contemporary Ministry of Information propaganda/recruiting poster highlighting surrender of U-570 to Coastal Command Hudson 27 August 1941 (RAF Museum FA 11020)Contemporary Ministry of Information propaganda/recruiting poster
    highlighting surrender of U-570 to Coastal Command Hudson 27 August 1941
    (RAF Museum FA 11020)

    An unique event occurred on 27 August 1941: the sole example of a submarine surrendering to an aircraft without the intervention of surface vessels. Hudsons from 269 Squadron were on patrol off Iceland when they spotted U-570 surfacing due to mechanical problems and with an inexperienced crew.

    Aircraft dropped depth charges, causing the crew to fear the damage had caused battery leaks and deadly chlorine gas being caused by the reaction with sea water, so they surrendered by waving white cloths. The Hudson pilot ceased fire and called for reinforcements.

    More aircraft arrived, including another Hudson and a Catalina from 209 Squadron, which had sunk U-452 just two days earlier. Despite U-570’s radio call for help, the swarm of RAF aircraft kept other U-boats at bay until an armed trawler arrived that evening to take possession of the submarine.

    Submarines Fight Back

    In the early years, a U-Boat would submerge as soon as an aircraft was sighted. But the Kriegsmarine realised how vulnerable the attacking aircraft were as they flew low (and slow) on their attack run so started mounting extensive anti-aircraft guns on the submarine, more powerful and longer-ranged than the modest aircraft armament. And the U-Boats began fighting back! Instead of diving when attacked, they would stay on the surface and fight.

    9. Type VIIC submarine U-361 under attack by Flight Lieutenant John Cruickshank; for sinking this he was awarded the Victoria Cross. Note splashes from aircraft machine guns and two twin flak mountings on conning tower. (RAF Museum X004-7598/11)Type VIIC submarine U-361 under attack by Flight Lieutenant John Cruickshank; for sinking this he was awarded the Victoria Cross. Note splashes from aircraft machine guns and two twin flak mountings on conning tower. (RAF Museum X004-7598/11)

    CC responded in two ways: improving aircraft armament; and developing ‘stand-off’ weapons. The Sunderland had only a nose turret with two 0.303 machine guns to fire against the U-Boat it was attacking whereas some U-Boats had multiple 20 mm cannon and even a 37 mm cannon to fire against an attacking aircraft. And early Liberators had no nose turret and just one 0.5 inch machine gun. So Sunderlands were fitted with an additional four fixed 0.303 machine guns whilst some Liberators had belly pods with four 20 mm cannon.

    Beaufighters, Mosquitoes and even Liberators had 8 Rocket Projectiles capable of penetrating the boats’ pressure hulls; on Liberators, they were on stub fittings below the cockpit.

    VLR Liberator. Note Rocket Projectiles rack below cockpit (RAF Museum AR P011963)VLR Liberator. Note Rocket Projectiles rack below cockpit (RAF Museum AR P011963)

    A limited number of Mosquitoes were even fitted with a Molins gun, a modified 3.7 inch (57 mm) army weapon also capable of breaking through a submarine’s pressure hull or hull of a merchant ship.

    Molins 6 pdr. Class M gun (RAF Museum Hendon)Molins 6 pdr. Class M gun (RAF Museum London)

    But as CC became bigger and better equipped, they wanted to go onto the offensive and prevent the U-Boats getting anywhere near a convoy, so they patrolled the Bay of Biscay, which U-Boats had to transit from their French bases to the deep Atlantic. The Germans retaliated by providing fighter escorts for the boats by Ju 88 twin-engined, highly effective fighters. So, in turn, the Liberators and Catalinas over the Bay of Biscay would have Beaufighter or Mosquito escorts.

    12. Pigeons join crew – carried to send position report home after ditching (RAF Museum AL00235)Pigeons join crew – carried to send position report home after ditching.
    (RAF Museum AL00235)

    Balance Sheet

    On 7 May 1945, the last U-boat to be sunk by an aircraft under RAF Coastal Command control, Type VIIC submarine U-320, was attacked by a Catalina of No.210 Squadron flown by Flight Lieutenant K.M. Murray. The submarine subsequently sank on 9 May off the Norwegian coast – none of the crew survived.

    Two files in The National Archives give an absolute wealth of statistics regarding Coastal Command’s equipment and activities: ‘Coastal Command War Statistics’ (AIR 15/685); and ‘Coastal Command Orders of Battle January 1944 to December 1947’ (AIR 15/703), of which the following is only the briefest of summaries.

    The Order of Battle for 6 June 1945 listed 13 UK bases plus Gibraltar, Azores and Iceland. And by now, others such as Dakar in West Africa, had already closed. CC aircraft were also operating in the India/Burma theatres but are counted under SEAC returns.

    Altogether, 23 basic types of aircraft were used (disregarding Mark number and ‘owner’ variants – such as Bomber Command, Fleet Air Arm, USAAF and USN operating under CC control).

    On 8 May 1945, total CC aircraft strength was 1,115, of which front-line maritime patrol, were:

    • Catalina/Canso 45
    • Halifax 27
    • Liberator 225
    • Sunderland 78
    • Wellington/Warwick 155

    Admiral Dönitz had been proven very wrong: the crows had pecked long and hard. Between 3 September 1939 and 8 May 1945, Royal Air Force, United States Army Air Force and United States Navy aircraft, all under RAF Coastal Command control, had destroyed 288 by aircraft alone, and a further 47 involving aircraft and surface warships.

    Around 120 aircraft were shot down by U-boats for the loss of roughly 30 U-boats either sunk during the attack or due to being located by other forces shortly afterwards and sunk. By the cruel and harsh statistics of war, that was a good result. Losses of life would have been roughly similar but a U-Boat demanded huge manufacturing resources and raw materials, taking long times to build. Whereas Henry Ford’s aircraft factory at Willow Run, Detroit, (the largest building in the world at that time) turned out one Liberator every 56 minutes.

    A total of 5,866 aircrew and 2,166 aircraft were lost on all CC operations whilst flying 238,300 sorties lasting 1,314,324 hours. Total personnel (RAF, WAAF, RAAF, RCAF, RNZAF and including refugee volunteers from Occupied Countries) rose from 11,600 on 1 January 1940 to 30,300 in July 1945.

    Coastal Command aircrew won four Victoria Crosses, three of them against U-Boats:

    Coastal Command is well represented in RAF Museum London: Short Sunderland, Bristol Beaufort, Bristol Beaufighter, Lockheed Hudson, Fairey Battle, Molins gun and Leigh Light.

    A Blog of some 3,000 words cannot begin even to scratch the surface of summaries of the longest campaign which was cruel and bloody and the most vital to Britain’s survival and ultimate victory; fought by many brave men on all sides: Royal Navy, Royal Air Force, Merchant Navy and other Allied forces. But not excluding the U-Boat crews who may have been fighting for an evil regime but they endured appalling losses – up to 70% killed – but still continued volunteering to the very end. This author encourages interested readers to undertake their own research and the following is a short summary of a few of the very many sources available.

    BIBLIOGRAPHY AND FURTHER READING
    • Coastal Command Review 1942-1945: a monthly digest of activities RAF Museum PR06052 – PR06058 [Author: classified Secret but written in popular magazine style]
    • Royal Air Force 1939-45, Official History in 3 volumes. Denis Richards and Hilary St G Saunders: HMSO 1953 Hardback and 1974 paperback (Available to study in the Museum’s Reading Room at Hendon.)
    • Aircraft versus Submarine, Alfred Price: William Kimber 1973
    • The U-Boat Hunters, Anthony Watts: Macdonald and Jane’s 1976

    [The above four sources are highly recommended by author]

    • Coastal Command at War, Chaz Bowyer: Ian Allan 1979
    • Coastal Command 1939-45 Photographs from the Imperial War Museum Ian Carter: Ian Allan 2004
    • Coastal Command in Action Photographs from the Public Record Office [now The National Archives] Roy Conyers Nesbit: Sutton Publishing 1997
    • Coastal Command 1939-1942 HMSO [wartime publicity book]
    • TNA AIR 15/99 Photos of a German submarine surrendering to the RAF Nos. 209 and 269 Squadrons (Reykjavik) 27th August 1941
    • TNA AIR 15/333 Coastal Command Order of Battle (Weekly) with location maps 5-2-43 – 14-6-43
    • AIR 15/685 Coastal Command War Statistics
    • AIR 15/702 Orders of Battle 1 July 1939 – 31 December 1943
    • AIR 15/703 Orders of Battle 1944-47
    • AIR 15/758 Coastal Command monthly summary of operations 1 October 1939 – 30 September 1941
    • AIR 27/469/1 Operations Record Book 48 Squadron 1 November 1935 – 30 September 1939 PDF
    • AIR 27/1179/36 Operations Record Book 201 Squadron June 1945
  • For Valour: Captain William Avery (‘Billy’) Bishop, VC, CB, DSO, MC, DFC, Croix de Guerre avec Palmes*

    For Valour: Captain William Avery (‘Billy’) Bishop, VC, CB, DSO, MC, DFC, Croix de Guerre avec Palmes*

    June 2nd, 1917, over France

    Billy Bishop8 February 1894 – 11 September 1956

    On the ground, fighting on the Western Front had been static since late 1914, with set piece battles by each side achieving gains measured in yards against casualties counted in the tens of thousands.

    In 1914, air power was virtually non-existent – aircraft barely able to support the weight of their pilots. First use was for reconnaissance – ‘what is over the next hill?’ – by the pilot taking paper notes. And artillery spotting, dropping target corrections to the artillery.

    Then they began to evolve.

    Reconnaissance aircraft with cameras. But you don’t want to let the enemy see what you are doing. So scout aircraft (now called fighters) to prevent them. And ground attack, with the development of role-specific design: scouts, reconnaissance and ground-support, then finally bombers.

    By 1917, air power was a tangible part of the fighting forces on both sides.

    Bishop with Nieuport 17, No. 60 Squadron, August 1916 - July 1917 (RAF Museum PC73/4/580)Bishop with Nieuport 17, No. 60 Squadron, August 1916 – July 1917
    (RAF Museum PC73/4/580)

    ‘Billy’ Bishop was the highest-scoring Commonwealth pilot of the Great War, officially credited with 72 enemy aircraft destroyed. In July 1915, Bishop joined the RFC as an Observer and started combat flying in France in January 1916. However, he later transferred to pilot training, gaining his RFC ‘wings’ at Upavon and on 9 March 1917 he was posted to 60 Squadron at Filecamp, France. He was subsequently promoted to Captain and given command of C Flight.

    4. Bishop in Nieuport 17, 60 Squadron (RAF Museum X003/2602/18145)Bishop in Nieuport 17, 60 Squadron (RAF Museum X003/2602/18145)

    On 2 June 1917, he embarked on a solo early-morning flight, for which he was awarded the VC. A full account of this action and his later career with the RFC and RCAF is contained in Bowyer’s ‘For Valour, the Air VCs’, a copy of which may be studied in the Reading Room of the RAF Museum, Hendon (see Bibliography).
    Victoria Cross medal set (Tilston Memorial Collection of Canadian Military Medals, Canadian War Museum CWM 19760521-110)Victoria Cross medal set
    (Tilston Memorial Collection of Canadian Military Medals, Canadian War Museum CWM 19760521-110)

    The London Gazette 11th August 1917

    ‘His Majesty the KING has been graciously pleased to approve of the award of the Victoria Cross to the undermentioned Officer: — Captain William Avery Bishop, D.S.O., M.C., Canadian Cavalry and Royal Flying Corps. For most conspicuous bravery, determination and skill. Captain Bishop, who had been sent out to work independently, flew first of all to an enemy aerodrome; finding no machine about, he flew on to another aerodrome about three miles south-east, which was at least twelve miles the other side of the line. Seven machines, some with their engines running, were on the ground.

    He attacked these from about fifty feet, and a mechanic, who was starting one of the engines, was seen to fall. One of the machines got oft the ground, but at a height of sixty feet Captain Bishop fired fifteen rounds into it at very close range, and it crashed to the ground. A second machine got off the ground, into which he fired thirty rounds at 150 yards range, and it fell into a tree.

    Two more machines then rose from the aerodrome. One of these he engaged at the height of 1,000 feet, emptying the rest of his drum of ammunition. This machine crashed 300 yards from the aerodrome, after which Captain Bishop emptied a whole drum into the fourth hostile machine, and then flew back to his station. Four hostile scouts were about 1,000 feet above him for about a mile of his return journey, but they would not attack. His machine was very badly shot about by machine gun fire from the ground.’

    Bishop’s VC is unique in that it is the only such award arising solely from the winner’s testimony: all other VCs have been awarded from the evidence of third parties, usually British, though occasionally German, eye-witnesses.

    This absence of independent evidence has given rise to debates over the veracity of Bishop’s combat report, a topic of no little acrimony, including even in the Canadian Parliament. Wing Commander William Mays Fry MC flew alongside Bishop during the summer of 1917 and subsequently wrote a paper challenging Bishop’s claims.

    The original typescript is held by RAF Museum (X007-5259/007), which was later published by Cross and Cockade in their Volume 32, No 1 of Spring 2001 and which may be studied in the Reading Room of RAF Museum London.

    Statement by Wing Commander William Mays Fry DFC (page 1) (RAF Museum X007-5259/007/001)

    Statement by Wing Commander William Mays Fry DFC (page 1)
    (RAF Museum X007-5259/007/001)

    During the Second World War, Bishop was very active, even appearing as himself in a cinema film ‘Captains of the Clouds’ aimed at recruitment to the RCAF. He was instrumental in setting up and promoting the British Commonwealth Air Training Plan. He finally retired on medical grounds as Air Vice-Marshal Bishop RCAF in 1944.

    His VC and Medal Bar is held by the Canadian War Museum, Ottawa.

    Grave and Memorial.Grave and Memorial

    He is buried in Greenwood Cemetery, Owen Sound, Ontario, Canada.

    Credits:

    • Citation: The London Gazette 11 August 1917
    • Additional biographical details: For Valour: The Air VCs Chaz Bowyer, Grub Street Publishing.
  • Arrest and Humiliation

    Arrest and Humiliation

    25 years ago the ban on LGBT+ people serving in the British Armed Forces was removed.

    When in 1967 homosexuality was legalised in British society, at the same time new legislation came into effect which forbade gay personnel from serving in the Armed Forces.

    On 12 January 2000 this law was repealed after the European Court of Human Rights ruled that it violated Article 8 of the Human Rights Act: the right to a private and family life.

    During the ban, anyone discovered to be gay could be subjected to arrest, interrogation, examination, imprisonment, and dismissal. To mark this important anniversary, the RAF Museum has been recording the experiences of those affected by the ban, with help from the military charity for dismissed LGBT+ veterans, Fighting with Pride , and the RAF LGBT+ Freedom Network of currently serving personnel.

    Each month we will share the perspectives of a selection of people who will discuss the impact of the ban and their treatment by the RAF at the time, which had a lasting effect on their lives.

    This month, in our fifth video, we are sharing a clip from Pádraigín Ní Rághillíg.

    She joined the RAF in 1976 but was dismissed in 1986 when it was discovered that she was in a relationship with a woman in the Women’s Royal Naval Service.

    Serving as a Telegraphist, she was on track for promotion to Corporal before the investigation into her sexuality began. Pádraigín was interrogated for several hours before being charged and eventually dismissed from the RAF.

    In this film, she talks about the overwhelming feelings that she had during the course of her initial ‘interview’.

    To learn more about her experience please visit rafstories.org at https://bit.ly/4mIxWjt

  • For Valour: Lt. (temp. Capt.) Albert Ball, VC, DSO**, MC, Legion d’Honneur (France); Order of St. George 4th Class (Russia). Late Notts. and Derby Regiment, and R.F.C.

    For Valour: Lt. (temp. Capt.) Albert Ball, VC, DSO**, MC, Legion d’Honneur (France); Order of St. George 4th Class (Russia). Late Notts. and Derby Regiment, and R.F.C.

    1. Portrait of Captain Albert Ball V.C. Oil on canvas Artist Noel Denholm (1876-1950) (Nottingham City Museums and Galleries NCM_1990-624)14 August 1896 – 7 May 1917
    Portrait of Captain Albert Ball V.C. Oil on canvas Artist Noel Denholm Davis (1876-1950) (Nottingham City Museums and Galleries NCM_1990-624)

    25 April – 6 May, 1917, over France

    On the ground, fighting on the Western Front had been static since late 1914, with set piece battles by each side achieving gains measured in yards against casualties counted in the tens of thousands. In 1914, air power was virtually non-existent – aircraft barely able to support the weight of their pilots.

    As the aircraft slowly evolved, so did their military use. First use was for reconnaissance – ‘what is over the next hill?’ – by the pilot taking paper notes. And artillery spotting, dropping target corrections to the artillery. Then they began to evolve. Reconnaissance aircraft with cameras.

    But you don’t want to let the enemy see what you are doing. So scout aircraft (now called fighters) to prevent them. And ground attack, with the development of role-specific design: scouts, reconnaissance and ground-support, then finally bombers. By 1917, air power was a tangible part of the fighting forces on both sides.

    2. Albert Ball's medals (Nottingham City Museums & Galleries NCM 1954-77/1=8)Albert Ball’s medals (Nottingham City Museums & Galleries NCM 1954-77/1=8)

    Albert Ball was awarded his RFC ‘wings’ brevet on 22 January 1916 and rapidly developed into a very dedicated and proficient fighter pilot, and perhaps amongst the best known and publicly admired. For a full description of his career and successes, see Bowyer’s ‘For Valour, the Air VCs’, a copy of which may be seen in the Reading Room of the RAF Museum, Hendon.

    On 25 February 1917, Ball was appointed to 56 Squadron at London Colney as commander of A flight, then re-equipping with Royal Aircraft Factory SE 5a scouts, and on 7 April, the squadron moved to its war station, Vert Galand airfield, near Amiens.

    At 6 pm on the evening of 7 May, 1917, Ball flew his personal SE 5a, serial A4850, on a ‘fighting patrol’ hunting for German aircraft. He encountered Jadgstaffel [fighter squadron] 11, commanded by the famous ace Baron Rittmeister Manfred von Richtofen but that day led by his younger brother, Lothar. The exact events that evening remain uncertain.

    Ball's personal SE 5a, in which he won his VC and died. (RAFM P012329) Ball’s personal SE 5a, in which he won his VC and died. (RAFM P012329)

    Lothar crashed with a defective engine and three German infantry officers saw Ball’s aircraft emerge from low cloud, inverted and emitting a thin plume of smoke. Ball was killed in the crash but examination of the aircraft showed no combat damage and Ball’s only injuries were from the impact.

    The London Gazette Friday 8 June 1917

    ‘Lt. (temp. Capt.) Albert Ball, D.S.O., M.C., late Notts, and Derby. R., and R.F.C. For most conspicuous and consistent bravery from the 25th of April to the 6th of May, 1917, during which period Capt. Ball took part in twenty-six combats in the air and destroyed eleven hostile aeroplanes, drove down two out of control, and forced several others to land.

    In these combats Capt. Ball, flying alone, on one occasion fought six hostile machines, twice he fought five and once four. When leading two other British aeroplanes he attacked an enemy formation of eight. On each of these occasions he brought down at least one enemy.

    Ball with squadron colleagues 17 April 1917: he died just 20 days later. (RAFM X004-7598) Ball with squadron colleagues 17 April 1917: he died just 20 days later.
    (RAFM X004-7598)

    Several times his aeroplane was badly damaged, once so seriously that but for the most delicate handling his machine would have collapsed, as nearly all the control wires had been shot away. On returning with a damaged machine he had always to be restrained from immediately going out on another.

    In all, Capt. Ball has destroyed forty-three German aeroplanes and one balloon, and has always displayed most exceptional courage, determination and skill.’

    5. Memorial at crash site (© The War Graves Photographic Project www.twgpp.org)Memorial and grave (© The War Graves Photographic Project www.twgpp.org)

    He is buried in Annoeullin Communal Cemetery And German Extension, the only British casualty there.

    Memorial at crash site (© The War Graves Photographic Project www.twgpp.org)
      Memorial at crash site (© The War Graves Photographic Project www.twgpp.org)

    His VC is held by City Museum and Art Gallery, Nottingham

    Credits:

    • Citation: The London Gazette Friday 8 June 1917
    • Additional biographical details: For Valour: The Air VCs Chaz Bowyer, Grub Street Publishing.
  • Operation Manna Remembered – Experiences of the Crews, Eighty Years On

    Operation Manna Remembered – Experiences of the Crews, Eighty Years On

    Exodus Chapter 16, v2-4, NIV:

    ‘In the desert the whole community grumbled against Moses and Aaron. The Israelites said to them, ‘If only we had died by the Lord’s hand in Egypt! There we sat round pots of meat and ate all the food we wanted, but you have brought us out into this desert to starve this entire assembly to death.’ Then the Lord said to Moses, ‘I will rain down bread from heaven for you..”’

    This portion of the ancient story of the Israelites tells of a nation saved from starvation by a raining down of supernatural food from the sky – called Manna – which was an experience that the Dutch nation could relate to at a time when their situation was equally desperate. Exactly eighty years ago this week, beginning on 29 April and extending to 8 May 1945, RAF Bomber Command undertook Operation Manna.

    Following a seemingly unending campaign of night bombing over Germany, this unusual task suggested to the bomber crews that the war might end any day soon. It was a fortnight of daily low-level flights daytime flights flown over German-occupied areas of the western Netherlands by crews of Lancasters bombers, used to flying at high-level and in darkness. This time, no bombs but sacks of food dropped to feed the malnourished population below. It was the first humanitarian aid mission undertaken buy the Royal Air Force and it left an indelible memory shared between the saved Dutch citizens and the crews who flew to their rescue. Held dear by those who experienced it, memories of Manna are treasured by their descendants today.

    The Dutch had already suffered five years of occupation by Germany and the requisition of much of its food resources, which had worsened in the months since D-Day when Western Holland suffered further with the effects of abandonment by an occupying army on the defence and only interested in feeding itself. An urgent solution to a population who had eaten the remaining food and were turning to sugar beet and inedible tulip bulbs to fill themselves, was needed.

    The Dutch Government in exile appealed to the Allies for immediate help. Codenamed Manna, to reflect the story of the Israelites led by Moses in the wilderness and being fed supernaturally with manna – bread from heaven – the urgently needed food supplies dropped from the air, were vital in saving some lives who were very close to starvation, after many more sick and elderly people had already died from malnourishment.

    A series of demanding food bombing raids followed over successive days, but happily and enthusiastically carried out by RAF crews, who knew that for once in this war, they were not destroying targets but directly saving the lives of their allies. Even in this final fortnight of the war in Europe, it didn’t mean the mission was simple – the enemy was still occupying the countryside where the bomber aircraft would fly over and the airfields designated for the food drops were still challenging targets to approach and deliver, undamaged, the vital food. Enemy infantry did sometimes still take shots at the low-flying aircraft, even if with few harmful consequences as the aircraft were so low, that shooting would be inaccurate.

    RAF Museum, X007/6957/003, Manna bomber approaching the coast of Holland.
    © RAF Museum, X007/6957/003, Manna bomber approaching the coast of Holland.

    An excellent full account of the operation, the reasons for it and its planning and execution, can be enjoyed in another RAF Museum blog, which I urge you to read and so I will not attempt to reproduce the story here.

    Instead, please see:
    https://www.rafmuseum.org.uk/blog/operation-manna-29th-april-to-8th-may-1945/

    The significant milestone of eighty years is a great opportunity to visit some first-hand accounts of a selection of RAF personnel who carried out these lifesaving missions and whose records, log books and unpublished accounts are held in our archive. We take a closer look here.

    In his unpublished squadron history, ‘We Fly By Marking, A History of No 582 Squadron RAF’, Albert Butterworth recalled:

    ‘Operation Manna … began during the day on April 29th 1945 and lasted until May 8th. During these ten days, 145 Mosquitoes and 300 Lancasters made 3,156 flights, dropping 6685 tons of food to the starving Dutch citizens.

    The hundreds of objects falling from the Lancasters, flying as low as 500ft (155m) and sometimes down to 300ft (91m), at 160mph (260kmh), were not bombs but bags of food, tins of butter, meat and cheese It was food which saved the lives of thousands of men, women and children, who for months had lived on a diet of boiled tulip bulbs, nettle soup and sliced beets, and were now at the end of their strength.

    In April 1945 the southern part of Holland had already been liberated by advancing allied troops after five years of German occupation, but north-western areas, Rotterdam, the Hague, Amsterdam were still in the hands of the Germans. Towards the end of 1944 after the Gestapo had opened dyke sluices, putting thousands of acres of fertile land under water, they demanded that the populace should surrender all food supplies to feed their troops. Dutch railwaymen went on strike in protest, which meant no food could be distributed.

    Eyewitnesses told of seeing people collapse on the street from hunger, while children were crying from starvation and exhaustion on doorsteps. Thousands of city dwellers trooped miles into the countryside, carrying pitiful bundles of table linen and their last clothes supplies to try to barter with farmers for potatoes, bread and milk.

    The RAF began planning in February 1945, when a Lancaster of 115 squadron (HK696) was sent to Netheravon to help in formulating a suitable dropping technique. Later, panniers were made, of which five could fit in a Lancaster’s bomb-bay, with each pannier holding 70 sacks, each containing 25lb (11kg), of tinned meat, flour, dried milk, chocolate, tea and sugar, etc, Hights were arranged at between 200 and 500 ft (60 to 152m), with the pilot selecting half-flap, and flying at between 110 and 120 knots (220 km/h).

    Dropping points were arranged to be marked by the Dutch authorities, and the leading aircraft was to mark the spot with a spot fire. No 115 squadron made the initial drop, and Lancasters took off from Witchford, Fiskerton and Stradishall, In all, seventeen Lancaster squadrons took part, undoubtedly averting s tragedy of enormous proportions.

    Forty years later, at 1pm, on 20th April 1985, this episode was remembered with thanksgiving ceremonies in the Netherlands during a general remembrance of VE Day throughout Europe.’
    Sergeant RS Fettes left his record of the event in no other form than his aircrew logbook, which although not recording any description or impressions of the event, as logbooks tend to record the bare facts of flights, the raw figures give a clear idea of the commitment made by the crews.

    Typical of this is the following entry for Monday 30 April 1945, the second day of Manna, which states:
    30.4.45 / Time – 1545 / Lancaster – LM132 “I” / Pilot – Pilot Officer McKenzie / Duty – Mid-Upper Gunner / Remarks, Ops. Manna, Food / Flying Times, Day – 3 hrs 15 mins

    Then again on Tuesday 1 May:
    1.5.45 / Time – 1429 / Lancaster – NG366 “F” / Pilot – Pilot Officer McKenzie / Duty – Mid-Upper Gunner / Remarks – Ops. Manna. Food. / Flying Times, Day – 3 hrs 45 mins

    And for Wednesday:
    2.5.45 / Time – 1224 / Lancaster – NG366 “F” / Pilot – Pilot Officer McKenzie / Duty – Mid-Upper Gunner / Remarks – Ops. Manna. Food. / Flying Times, Day – 3 hrs 5 mins

    Then Thursday:
    3.5.45 / Time – 1141 / Lancaster – RA566 “K” / Pilot – Pilot Officer McKenzie / Duty – Mid-Upper Gunner / Remarks – Ops. Manna. Food. / Flying Times, Day – 3 hrs 10 mins

    Then following a break in his flying schedule, Fettes’ final Manna entry is on Monday 7 May:
    7.5.45 / Time – 1315 / Lancaster – (serial unrecorded) “P” / Pilot – Pilot Officer McKenzie / Duty – Mid-Upper Gunner / Remarks – Ops. Manna. Food. / Flying Times, Day – 3 hrs 40 mins

    The Battle of Britain Memorial Flight Lancaster BomberThe Battle of Britain Memorial Flight’s Lancaster© Author

    © RAF Museum, B3484; Air gunner's flying log book of Sgt R.S Fettes, 1942-1943

    © RAF Museum, B3484; Air gunner’s flying log book of Sgt R.S Fettes, 1942-1943

    What stands out here is the consistent flight time of between three and four hours, the necessity to do this in the day so that the food can be seen and retrieved by the Dutch officials, (in contrast to the many night raids the crew would have been familiar with), and the pattern of starting out times tending to be in the afternoon. The fiddly routine of loading the food packages into the bomb bay of the aircraft, took the best part of the morning, hence always going over in the afternoon.

    X007/6957/002 Food sacks loaded into the bomb bay of a LancasterX007/6957/002 Food sacks loaded into the bomb bay of a Lancaster.

    The log book of Bomb Aimer, Flight Sergeant R Davies tells a similar story, this time revealing the locations of the drops, (Air Bomber’s flying log book of FS R Davies, 2 December 1943-28 June 1945):

    29.4.45 / Time – 1310 / Lancaster – U / Pilot – Flying Officer Cowley / Duty – Air Bomber / Remarks, Ops. 19 Rotterdam (supply dropping) / Flying Times, Day – 2 hrs 35 mins

    1.5.45 / Time – 1345 / Lancaster – Q / Pilot – Flying Officer Cowley / Duty – Air Bomber / Remarks, Hague (supply dropping) / Flying Times, Day – 2 hrs 30 mins

    3.5.45 / Time – 1130 / Lancaster – W / Pilot – Flying Officer Cowley / Duty – Air Bomber / Remarks, Hague (supply dropping) / Flying Times, Day – 2 hrs 10 mins

    4.5.45 / Time – 1135 / Lancaster – X / Pilot – Flying Officer Cowley / Duty – Air Bomber / Remarks, Hague (supply dropping) / Flying Times, Day – 2 hrs 35 mins

    © RAF Museum, X005-0931/001; Air Bomber's flying log book of FS R. Davies, 2 December 1943-28 June 1945

    © RAF Museum, X005-0931/001; Air Bomber’s flying log book of FS R. Davies,
    2 December 1943-28 June 1945

    In his account of 550 Squadron, Through Fire We Conquer, Jack Kendall relates one pilot’s experience:
    ‘Pilot John Carsons from 550 Sqn recorded his impressions of one of these ops. “We crossed the coast at the island of Overflakkee and flew east. We were constantly greeted by countless people waving at us enthusiastically. Next to a smallish village we dropped our Manna and self written leaflets and after some sightseeing we turned northwest and returned to North Killingholme.” On 7th May, the day before the war ended 550 Sqn were over Holland again this time dropping many tons of food to the people of Rotterdam.”’

    The urgent need for Operation Manna and its life saving potential had called for a rapid response at scale, and the crews of Bomber Command responded to that as professionally as in their bombing missions, but in doing so had invested themselves in a mission of mercy and selflessness that would remain in their memories for the rest of their lives.

    Below is a link to some Manna artefacts and images that can be viewed on our online inventory of selected items from Royal Air Force Museum Collections.

  • For Valour : 2nd Lieutenant William Barnard Rhodes-Moorhouse VC

    For Valour : 2nd Lieutenant William Barnard Rhodes-Moorhouse VC

    William Rhodes-Moorhouse VC (RAFM 00037153)

    26 September 1887 – 27 April 1915

    April 26th 1915, over France

    Lieutenant Rhodes-Moorhouse has the distinction of being the first aviator to be awarded the Victoria Cross.
    Rhode- House's Victoria CrossRhodes-Moorhouse’s VC

    On the ground, fighting on the Western Front had been static since late 1914, with set piece battles by each side achieving gains measured in yards against casualties counted in the tens of thousands. In 1914, air power was virtually non-existent – aircraft barely able to support the weight of their pilots. As the aircraft slowly evolved, so did their military use. First use was for reconnaissance – ‘what is over the next hill?’ – by the pilot taking paper notes. And artillery spotting, dropping target corrections to the artillery. Then adding bombs to these observation aircraft.

    Mechanic about to swing the propeller of Royal Aircraft Factory BE2b, c 1916 (RAFM P031251)Mechanic about to swing the propeller of Royal Aircraft Factory BE2b,
    c 1916 (RAFM P031251)

    On 20 March 1915, Rhodes-Moorhouse was appointed to No. 2 Squadron, Royal Flying Corps, based at Merville, France and equipped with BE 2 aircraft. This was a safe and stable machine but its 70 hp Renault engine limited speed to a meagre 70 mph; it could carry an observer or 100 lb bomb. But not both.

    4. BE2b of 4 Squadron, close-up of cockpit interior, St Omer (RAFM P001878)

    BE2b of 4 Squadron, close-up of cockpit interior, St Omer (RAFM P001878)

    On 22 April 1915, German forces deployed a new and terrifying weapon for the first time, during the first battle of Ypres: chlorine poison gas. French troops fell back in disarray and German troops were identified as assembling at rail heads to exploit any breaks in the front line. Thus, on 26 April, 2 Squadron was ordered to attack the railway station at Courtrai. Rhodes-Moorhouse was flying BE2b serial 687.

    The London Gazette Friday 21st May 1915

    ‘2nd Lieutenant William Barnard Rhodes-Moorhouse, Special Reserve, Royal Flying Corps. For most conspicuous bravery on 26th April, 1915, in flying to Courtrai and dropping bombs on the railway line near that station. On starting the return journey he was mortally wounded, but succeeded in flying for 35 miles to his destination, at a very low altitude, and reported the successful accomplishment of his object. He has since died of his wounds.’

    5. All RAF Transport Command VC 10 aircraft carried the name of an RFC/RAF VC winner; this is XV 108 (Photo courtesy of East Midlands Aeropark Aviation Museum, where this nose section is on display) All RAF Transport Command VC 10 aircraft carried the name of an RFC/RAF VC winner; this is XV 108 (Photo courtesy of East Midlands Aeropark Aviation Museum, where this nose section is on display)

    That particular edition of the London Gazette listed no fewer than 5 Victoria Crosses so the entry is perhaps more brief than usual. More details can be found in ‘For Valour’ by Chaz Bowyer, a copy of which may be viewed in the RAF Museum’s Reading Room in Hendon (see Bibliography).

    He is buried in a private grave at Parnham House, near Beaminster, Dorset

     

    Family burial plot (© The War Graves Photographic Project www.twgpp.org)
         Family burial plot (© The War Graves Photographic Project www.twgpp.org)

    His VC is held by the Imperial War Museum, London.

    Credits:

    • Citation: The London Gazette Friday 21st May 1915
    • Additional biographical details: For Valour: The Air VCs Chaz Bowyer, Grub Street Publishing.

     

     

  • Fighting with Pride – Success

    Fighting with Pride – Success

    25 years ago the ban on LGBT+ people serving in the British Armed Forces was removed.

    When in 1967 homosexuality was legalised in British society, at the same time new legislation came into effect which forbade gay personnel from serving in the Armed Forces.

    On 12 January 2000 this law was repealed after the European Court of Human Rights ruled that it violated Article 8 of the Human Rights Act: the right to a private and family life.

    During the ban, anyone discovered to be gay could be subjected to arrest, interrogation, examination, imprisonment, and dismissal. To mark this important anniversary, the RAF Museum has been recording the experiences of those affected by the ban, with help from the military charity for dismissed LGBT+ veterans, Fighting with Pride , and the RAF LGBT+ Freedom Network of currently serving personnel.

    Each month we will share the perspectives of a selection of people who will discuss the impact of the ban and their treatment by the RAF at the time, which had a lasting effect on their lives.

    This month, in our fourth video, we are sharing a clip from Ken Wright.

    Ken received the RAF Police Baton of Honour and in 1990 he was awarded the personal commendation of ACM Hine for Services to the RAF.

    After Ken realised that he was gay he was required to leave ‘due to circumstances outwith his control’.

    He went on to have a successful career in civil aviation and is a founding member of “Fighting with Pride”, a charity that supports veterans in the LGBTQIA+ community.

    In this video, he considers the real achievement of Fighting with Pride – the fact that former military personnel who had been discharged due to who they loved where able to come together for the first time and share their experiences. To learn more about Ken’s experience please visit rafstories.org at https://bit.ly/4jrBS5p

  • For Valour: 2nd Lt. (Temporary Captain) [later Major] James Byford McCudden, DSO*, MC*, MM, Croix de Guerre, General List and Royal Flying Corps.

    For Valour: 2nd Lt. (Temporary Captain) [later Major] James Byford McCudden, DSO*, MC*, MM, Croix de Guerre, General List and Royal Flying Corps.

    James McCudden VC28 March 1895 – 9 July 1918

    April 2, 1918,Over France

    Captain McCudden’s Victoria Cross is exceptional as it was awarded, not for one particular event of Valour, but for his long operational fighting career, consistent prowess and devotion to duty. He was awarded no fewer than seven awards for gallantry.

    He was also a rare example in those times of strict class hierarchy of a soldier selected for pilot training who rose from the most basic rank and was subsequently granted a Commission; trainee pilots then being largely selected from those already of officer rank. It is also noteworthy that, although he signed on as a Boy Soldier in 1910, aged 15, he was a Major at his death.

    James McCudden's VC Obverse and ReverseJames McCudden’s Victoria Cross
    (Photographs reproduced with the kind permission of
    the Royal Engineers Museum, Library & Archive)

     

    For a detailed biography and record of his military career, this author commends ‘For Valour: The Air VCs’ (see bibliography), a copy of which is held by the RAF Museum’s Reading Room in London.

    On the ground, fighting on the Western Front had been static since late 1914, with set piece battles by each side achieving gains measured in yards against casualties counted in the tens of thousands. In 1914, air power was virtually non-existent – aircraft barely able to support the weight of their pilots.

    McCudden beside his Vickers F.B. 16D Serial A8963 (RAF Museum PC/74/17/52)McCudden beside his Vickers F.B. 16D Serial A8963 (RAF Museum PC/74/17/52)

    First use was for reconnaissance – ‘what is over the next hill?’ – by the pilot taking paper notes. And artillery spotting, dropping target corrections to the artillery. Then they began to evolve. Reconnaissance aircraft with cameras. But you don’t want to let the enemy see what you are doing.

    So scout aircraft (now called fighters) to prevent them. And ground attack, with the development of role-specific design: scouts, reconnaissance and ground-support, then finally bombers. By 1917, air power was a tangible part of the fighting forces on both sides.

    McCudden seated in SE 5a (RAF Museum PC/74/17/189)McCudden seated in an SE 5a (RAF Museum PC/74/17/189)

    The London Gazette Tuesday 2 April 1918

    ‘His Majesty the KING has been graciously pleased to approve of the award of the Victoria Cross to the undermentioned Officer: — 2nd Lt. (T./Capt.) James Byford McCudden, D.S.O., M.C., M.M., Gen. List and R.F.C. for most conspicuous bravery, exceptional perseverance, keenness, and very high devotion to duty.

    Captain McCudden has at the present time accounted for 54 enemy aeroplanes! Of these 42 have been definitely destroyed, 19 of them on our side of the lines. Only 12 out of the 54 have been driven out of control. On two occasions, he has totally destroyed four two-seater enemy aeroplanes on the same day, and on the last occasion all four machines were destroyed in the space of 1 hour and 30 minutes.

    'S.E.5a of 56 Squadron flying left to right, whilst Hannover descends after being shot down by McCudden.' Artist Edgar J. March (RAF Museum FA 03208)‘S.E.5a of 56 Squadron flying left to right, whilst Hannover descends after being shot down by McCudden.’ Artist Edgar J. March (RAF Museum FA 03208)

    While in his present squadron he has participated in 78 offensive patrols, and in nearly every case has been the leader. On at least 30 other occasions, whilst with the same squadron, he has crossed the lines alone, either in pursuit or in quest of enemy aero-planes.

    The following incidents are examples of the work he has done recently: — On the 23rd December, 1917, when leading his patrol, eight enemy aeroplanes were attacked between 2.30 p.m. and 3.50 p.m. Of these two were shot down by Captain McCudden in our lines.

    Combat report by McCudden 9 January 1918 (RAF Museum AC1997/93/356002)Combat report by McCudden 9 January 1918
    (RAF Museum AC1997/93/356002)

     

    On the morning of the same day he left the ground at 10.50am and encountered four enemy aeroplanes; of these he shot two down. On the 30th January, 1918, he, single-handed, attacked five enemy scouts, as a result of which two were destroyed.

    On this occasion he only returned home when the enemy scouts had been driven far east; his Lewis gun ammunition was all finished and the belt of his Vickers gun had broken. As a patrol leader he has at all times shown the utmost gallantry and skill, not only in the manner in which he has attacked and
    destroyed the enemy, but in the way he has during several aerial fights protected the newer members of his flight, thus keeping down their casualties to a minimum.

    Rumpler C.V. shot down by McCudden near Mazingarbe 21 October1917 (RAF Museum PC74/17/82Rumpler C.V. shot down by McCudden near Mazingarbe 21 October 1917
    (RAF Museum PC74/17/82)

    This officer is considered, by the record, which he has made, by his fearlessness, and by the great service which he has rendered to his country, deserving of the very highest honour.’

    Major McCudden died in a flying accident whilst returning to the Western Front from an appointment commanding a training establishment in Scotland.

    McCudden's GraveGrave (© The War Graves Photographic Project www.twgpp.org)

    He lies in the Commonwealth War Graves Commission’s Wavans British Cemetery.

    His VC is held by the Royal Engineers Museum, Chatham.

    Credits:

    • Citation: London Gazette 2 April 1918
    • Additional biographical details: For Valour: The Air VCs Chaz Bowyer, Grub Street Publishing.
  • For Valour: Lieutenant Alan Jerrard, Royal Air Force VC, MVB

    For Valour: Lieutenant Alan Jerrard, Royal Air Force VC, MVB

    Lt. Alan Jerrard, VC, Royal Air Force (formerly of the South Staffordshire Regiment) (RAF Museum 028/001)

    3 December 1897 – 14 May 1968

    March 30, 1918, over Italy

    Lieutenant Jerrard has the distinction of being the only member of the RFC/RAF to have been awarded a VC on the Italian Front, where British and Italian armies were facing Austro-Hungarian forces.
    Jerrard's personal VC (RAF Museum 80D551) Jerrard’s personal VC (RAF Museum 80D551)

    Lieutenant Jerrard was a member of 66 Squadron based at San Pietro-in-Gu, just north of Gossa. On 30 March, 1918, he and two other pilots flew an offensive patrol towards Austrian lines; Jerrard was in Sopwith Camel B5648.

    Sopwith Camel with unknown RFC officers (RAF Museum X003-2602/1544)Sopwith Camel with unknown RFC officers (RAF Museum X003-2602/1544)

    THE LONDON GAZETTE WEDNESDAY, 1 MAY, 1918

    ‘His Majesty the KING has been graciously pleased to award the Victoria Cross to the undermentioned Officer of the Royal Air Force, for services displaying outstanding bravery: — Lt. Alan Jerrard, Royal Air Force (formerly of the South Staffordshire Regiment).

    Sopwith Camel in flight (RAF Museum X003-2602/15886)Sopwith Camel in flight (RAF Museum X003-2602/15886)

    When on an offensive patrol with two other officers he attacked five enemy aeroplanes and shot one down in flames, following it down to within one hundred feet of the ground. He then attacked an enemy aerodrome from a height of only fifty feet from the ground, and, engaging single-handed some nineteen machines, which were either landing or attempting to take off, succeeded in destroying one of them, which crashed on the aerodrome.

    5. Restored Sopwith Camel at RAF Museum MidlandsRestored Sopwith Camel at RAF Museum London circa 2014

    A large number of machines then attacked him, and whilst thus fully occupied “he observed that one of the pilots of his patrol was in difficulties”. He went immediately to his assistance, regardless of his own personal safety, and destroyed a third enemy machine. Fresh enemy aeroplanes continued to rise from the aerodrome, which he attacked one after another, and only retreated, still engaged with five enemy machines, when ordered to do so by his patrol leader.

    Jerrard captured by Austrian troops after crashing (RAF Museum PC/71/19/28/4)Jerrard captured by Austrian troops after crashing (RAF Museum PC/71/19/28/4)

    Although apparently wounded, this very gallant officer turned repeatedly, and attacked single-handed the pursuing machines, until he was eventually overwhelmed by numbers and driven to the ground. Lt. Jerrard had greatly distinguished himself on four previous occasions, within a period of twenty-three days, in destroying enemy machines, displaying bravery and ability of the very highest order.’

    An image of Jerrard's crashed aircraft

    Image reference: (RAF Museum X004-7598/021)

    The exact circumstances of the combats for which the VC were awarded are contentious: the British and Austrian records differing markedly. A comprehensive analysis may be found in Bowyer’s ‘For Valour’, a copy of which is held by the RAF Museum’s Reading Room in London (see Bibliography).

    At the end of the action, Jerrard was finally shot down and captured, spending the remainder of the war as a PoW. After repatriation, he resumed an RAF career but in 1933 was forced by ill health to retire.

    He was cremated at the Exeter & Devon Crematorium, Exeter; his ashes were interred at Uxbridge and Hillingdon Cemetery, Middlesex, where his name is incorporated into a family headstone.

    Jerrard family grave (Author via The War Graves Photographic Project www.twgpp.org)Jerrard family grave
    (Author via The War Graves Photographic Project www.twgpp.org)

    His VC is held by the Royal Air Force Museum. The decoration ‘M.V.B.’ is the Italian Medaglia al Valore di Bronzo (Medal for Valour, Bronze).

    Credits:

    • Citation: London Gazette 1 May 1918
    • Additional biographical details: For Valour: The Air VCs Chaz Bowyer, Grub Street Publishing.
    • Grave photo: Author via The War Graves Photographic Project (www.twgpp.org)
  • For Valour: 2nd Lieutenant Alan Arnett McLeod, VC Royal Air Force

    For Valour: 2nd Lieutenant Alan Arnett McLeod, VC Royal Air Force

    Lieutenant Alan McLeod VC (RAF Museum X004-7598/030)

    20 April 1899 – 9 November 1918

    27 March 1918, over France

    After 3 years of static trench warfare, on 21 March 1918 the Great War became mobile again. With the collapse of Russian forces in the east, the German Army was able to move vast numbers of troops to the Western Front, culminating in an attack on a broad aspect. Where, until now, advances by each side could be measured in yards, the Germans penetrated deeply.

    Lieutenant McLeod was a member of 2 Squadron, RFC, based at Hesdigneul, France, which was equipped with Armstrong Whitworth FK8 two-seat aircraft, nicknamed the ‘Big-Ack’ on account of their size. They were used for bombing, photographic and general reconnaissance duties. On 21 March 1918, the German armies launched a major offensive, causing many RFC units to be hurriedly moved to the Amiens and Bapaume battle area. On 27 March, McLeod was undertaking a bombing attack in FK 8 serial B5773 with Lieutenant Hammond MC as his Observer.

    McLeod second from left, with stick (RAF Museum X004-7598/030)McLeod second from left, with stick (RAF Museum X004-7598/030)

    The London Gazette 1 May 1918:

    ‘2nd Lt Alan Arnett McLeod, Royal Air Force

    Whilst flying with his observer (Lt. A W. Hammond, M C.), attacking hostile formations by bombs and machine-gun fire, he was assailed at a height of 5,000 feet by eight enemy triplanes, which dived at him from all directions, firing from their front guns.

    Victoria Cross Medal Set, Lieutenant Alan McLeod, V.C. (CWM 19670076-001 Tilston Memorial Collection of Canadian Military Medals, Canadian War Museum, Ottawa
    Victoria Cross Medal Set, Lieutenant Alan McLeod, V.C.
    (CWM 19670076-001 Tilston Memorial Collection of Canadian Military Medals, Canadian War Museum, Ottawa)

    By skilful manoeuvring he enabled his observer to fire bursts at each machine in turn, shooting three of them down out of control. By this time Lt McLeod had received five wounds, and whilst continuing the engagement a bullet penetrated his petrol tank and set the machine on fire. He then climbed out on to the left bottom plane, controlling his machine from the side of the fuselage, and by side-slipping steeply kept the flames to one side, thus enabling the observer to continue firing until the ground was reached.

    Armstrong Whitworth FK 8 (RAF Museum 008)Armstrong Whitworth FK 8 (RAF Museum 008)

    The observer had been wounded six times when the machine crashed in “No Man’s Land,” and 2nd Lt McLeod, notwithstanding his own wounds, dragged him away from the burning wreckage at great personal risk from heavy machine-gun fire from the enemy’s lines. This very gallant pilot was wounded by a bomb whilst engaged in this act of rescue, but he persevered until he had placed Lt Hammond in comparative safety, before falling himself from exhaustion and loss of blood.’

    Lieutenant McLeod’s wounds were such that he never flew again. He was sent back home to Canada in September 1918 to convalesce but on 6 November, he succumbed to the virulent Spanish Influenza pandemic, exacerbated by his war wounds.

    Christmas card by No. 2 Squadron celebrating McLeod's VC (RAF Museum X005-0925/002/003)
    Christmas card by No. 2 Squadron celebrating McLeod’s VC (RAF Museum X005-0925/002/003)

    NOTE: McLeod is described as Royal Air Force as that was the force in which he was serving at the time the award was Gazetted but he was a member of the Royal Flying Corps at the time of the action.

    He lies in Winnipeg (Kildonan) Presbyterian Cemetery, Winnipeg, Canada. His VC is held by the Canadian War Museum, Ottawa.

    McLeod family headstone (© The War Grave Photographic Project www/twgpp.org)McLeod family headstone
    (© The War Grave Photographic Project www/twgpp.org)

    Credits:

    • Citation: London Gazette 1 May 1918
    • Additional biographical details: For Valour: The Air VCs Chaz Bowyer, Grub Street Publishing.
    • Grave photo: © The War Graves Photographic Project (www.twgpp.org)
  • For Valour : Lieutenant Francis Hubert (Frank) McNamara, VC, Australian Forces, Royal Flying Corps

    For Valour : Lieutenant Francis Hubert (Frank) McNamara, VC, Australian Forces, Royal Flying Corps

    1. Frank McNamara VC (RAF Museum X004-7598/031)

    4 April 1894 – 2 November 1961

    March 20, 1917, over Palestine

    In the Middle East, Britain was fighting German and Turkish forces over a wide area, from the Mediterranean coast to the trackless deserts, with air power an essential element of force formations, given the vast distances to be covered. In addition to the natural perils of heat and thirst from a forced landing in the desert, Turkish troops had a fearsome reputation – whether deserved or not – amongst British servicemen for cruelty to prisoners, so every effort was made to recover any downed airman in enemy-held territory.

    2. McNamara's personal VC (RAF Museum 910199D)

    McNamara’s personal VC (RAF Museum 910199D)

    Frank McNamara had the distinction of being the only Australian to be awarded a Victoria Cross for aerial activities in the First World War [Great War]. On 20 March 1917, McNamara was a member of 1 Squadron, Australian Flying Corps, ordered to bomb a Turkish railway train near Wadi Hesse, Gaza. McNamara was pilot of a Martinsyde G 100 fighter serial 7486, modified to carry bombs. The attacking force also included a Royal Aircraft Factory BE 2c serial 4479, piloted by Captain Rutherford.

    3. Martinsyde G 100 Scout (RAF Museum X003-2602-8248)Martinsyde G 100 Scout (RAF Museum X003-2602-8248)

    The London Gazette Friday 8 June 1917:

    ‘For most conspicuous bravery and devotion to duty during an aerial bomb attack upon a hostile construction train, when one of our pilots was forced to land behind the enemy’s lines, Lt. McNamara, observing this pilot’s predicament and the fact that hostile cavalry were approaching, descended to his rescue.

    He did this under heavy rifle fire and in spite of the fact that he himself had been severely wounded in the thigh. He landed about 200 yards from the damaged machine, the pilot of which climbed on to Lt. McNamara’s machine, and an attempt was made to rise.

    A photograph of what is believed to be the machine McNamara flew for his VC mission (RAF Museum X004-7598/031) A photograph of what is believed to be the machine McNamara
    flew for his VC mission
    (RAF Museum X004-7598/031)

    Owing, however, to his disabled leg, Lt. McNamara was unable to keep his machine straight, and it turned over. The two officers, having extricated themselves, immediately set fire to the machine and made their way across to the damaged machine, which they succeeded in starting. Finally Lt. McNamara, although weak from loss of blood, flew this machine back to the aerodrome, a distance of seventy miles, and thus completed his comrade’s rescue.’

    A much fuller description of this action than the London Gazette’s version is contained in ‘For Valour’ (see bibliography), which this author commends; a copy may be consulted in the Reading Room at RAF Museum London.

    Royal Aircraft Factory BE 2c (RAF Museum X003-2602/9941)
    Royal Aircraft Factory BE 2c (RAF Museum X003-2602/9941)

    After the Armistice, McNamara enjoyed a highly meritorious career in both the Royal Australian Air Force and, latterly, the Royal Air Force. He retired in July 1946 as Air Vice-Marshal McNamara VC, CB, CBE.

    His VC is held by RAF Museum London.

    McNamara's GraveGrave marker
    (Taken by the author via The War Graves Photographic Project www.twgpp.org)

    He is buried in St Joseph’s Church Cemetery, Chalfont St Peter, Gerrards Cross, Buckinghamshire.

    Credits:

    • Citation: London Gazette Friday 8 June 1917
    • Additional biographical details: For Valour: The Air VCs Chaz Bowyer, Grub Street Publishing
  • Incompatible with Service Life

    Incompatible with Service Life

    Carl Austin-BehanCarl Austin-Behan

    25 years ago the ban on LGBT+ people serving in the British Armed Forces was removed.

    When in 1967 homosexuality was legalised in British society, at the same time new legislation came into effect which forbade gay personnel from serving in the Armed Forces.

    On 12 January 2000 this law was repealed after the European Court of Human Rights ruled that it violated Article 8 of the Human Rights Act: the right to a private and family life.

    During the ban, anyone discovered to be gay could be subjected to arrest, interrogation, examination, imprisonment, and dismissal. To mark this important anniversary, the RAF Museum has been recording the experiences of those affected by the ban, with help from the military charity for dismissed LGBT+ veterans, Fighting with Pride , and the RAF LGBT+ Freedom Network of currently serving personnel.

    Each month we will share the perspectives of a selection of people who will discuss the impact of the ban and their treatment by the RAF at the time, which had a lasting effect on their lives.

    This month, in our third video, we are sharing a clip from Carl Austin-Behan.

    During his service as a firefighter in the Royal Air Force, Carl Austin-Behan rescued a pilot from a burning aircraft.

    He was awarded the Good Show Award for Bravery, The Royal Human Society Bronze Award and received a mention in the Queen’s Birthday Honours List.

    In 1997 Carl was dismissed from the RAF after his sexuality came to light in a time where being Homosexual in the British Armed Forces was not permitted.

    Carl was crowned Mr Gay UK in 2001 and would later become Manchester’s first openly gay Lord Mayor, using both positions to promote the achievements and contributions of the LGBT community.

    In the above video Carl talks about what it was about how his dismissal from the RAF that upset him the most.

    Learn more about Carl’s story and the stories other current and former serving members of the LGBTQIA+ community in the RAF, here.

     

  • For Valour : Flight Lieutenant William (Bill) Ellis Newton (Aus. 250748) VC, Royal Australian Air Force

    For Valour : Flight Lieutenant William (Bill) Ellis Newton (Aus. 250748) VC, Royal Australian Air Force

    Newton in Flying Kit

    8 June 1919 – 29 March 1943
    Newton in flying kit (RAF Museum PC/76/23/5)

    As well as providing thousands of airmen to the RAF to fight in Europe and the Mediterranean area, Australia had its own war much nearer home: defending their homeland and fighting the Japanese in New Guinea and the South West Pacific. Newton was the only Australian airman to have been awarded his VC under the direct control of the RAAF, as against serving as part of the larger RAF, and on the advice of the Australian Government. And, in common with Group Captain Leonard Cheshire VC, RAF, his award was for lengthy and dedicated service, rather than one single act.

    Medal Bar (Australian War Memorial Museum RELAWM 32315.001)

    Newton’s Medal Bar (Australian War Memorial Museum RELAWM 32315.001)

    Throughout the period mentioned in the London Gazette, Newton was a member of 22 Squadron, RAAF, based at Ward’s Field, Port Moresby, flying Douglas Boston A-20 aircraft on ‘intruder’ missions. On 17 March 1943, Newton was captain and pilot of Boston serial A28-3, coded DU-Y. He was tasked with attacking Japanese port and storage facilities at Salamaua on the north coast.

    The London Gazette Friday 15th October 1943

    ‘The KING has been graciously pleased, on the advice of Australian Ministers, to confer the VICTORIA CROSS on the undermentioned officer in recognition of most conspicuous bravery: — Flight Lieutenant William Ellis NEWTON (Aus. 748), Royal Australian Air Force, No. 22 (R.A.A.F.) Squadron (missing).

    Flight Lieutenant Newton served with No. 22 Squadron, Royal Australian Air Force, in New Guinea from May, 1942, to March, 1943, and completed 52 operational sorties. Throughout, he displayed great courage and an iron determination to inflict the utmost damage on the enemy. His splendid offensive flying and fighting were attended with brilliant success. Disdaining evasive tactics when under the heaviest fire, he always went straight to his objectives.

    He carried out many daring machine-gun attacks on enemy positions involving low-flying over long distances in the face of continuous fire at point-blank range. On three occasions, he dived through intense anti-aircraft fire to release his bombs on important targets on the Salamaua Isthmus. On one of these occasions, his starboard engine failed over the target, but he succeeded in flying back to an airfield 160 miles away.

    Douglas Bostons of 22 Squadron RAAF in New Guinea, 1943 (Australian War Memorial Museum AC 0031)Douglas Bostons of 22 Squadron RAAF in New Guinea, 1943
    (Australian War Memorial Museum AC 0031)

    When leading an attack on an objective on 16th March, 1943, he dived through intense and accurate shell fire and his aircraft was hit repeatedly. Nevertheless, he held to his course and bombed his target from a low level. The attack resulted in the destruction of many buildings and dumps, including two 40,000 fuel installations.

    Although his aircraft was crippled, with fuselage and wing sections torn, petrol tanks pierced, main-planes and engines seriously damaged, and one of the main tyres flat, Flight Lieutenant Newton managed to fly it back to base and make a successful landing. Despite this harassing experience, he returned next day to the same locality.

    His target, this time a single building, was even more difficult but he again attacked with his usual courage and resolution, flying a steady course through a barrage of fire. He scored a hit on the building but at the same moment his aircraft burst into flames. Flight Lieutenant Newton maintained control and calmly turned his aircraft away and flew along the shore.

    He saw it as his duty to keep the aircraft in the air as long as he could so as to take his crew as far away as possible from the enemy’s positions. With great skill, he brought his blazing aircraft down on the water. Two members of the crew were able to extricate themselves and were seen swimming to the shore, but the gallant pilot is missing.

    According to other air crews who witnessed the occurrence, his escape-hatch was not opened and his dinghy was not inflated. Without regard to his own safety, he had done all that man could do to prevent his crew from falling into enemy hands. Flight Lieutenant Newton’s many examples of conspicuous bravery have rarely been equalled and will serve as a shining inspiration to all who follow him.’

    The London Gazette reported him as ‘missing’ but the reality was more tragic. Bowyer’s ‘For Valour’ [see Bibliography] records that Newton and one of his crew, Flight Sergeant Lyon, managed to escape from the sinking aircraft; the third crew member, Sergeant Eastwood, was lost. Both men swam ashore but were soon captured by Japanese troops. John Lyon was executed by the Japanese on 20 March 1943 and his gallant captain, Bill Newton, on 29 March. [Both dates of death confirmed from Commonwealth War Graves Commission records.]

    Newton's Grave (© Commonwealth War Graves Commission, by permission)

    Their graves are tended by the Commonwealth War Graves Commission in Lae War Cemetery, Papua New Guinea.

    His VC is held by the Australian War Memorial Museum. Canberra.

    Credits:

    • Citation: The London Gazette Friday 15th October 1943
    • Additional biographical details: For Valour: The Air VCs Chaz Bowyer, Grub Street Publishing.
  • The Etherton Report

    The Etherton Report

    25 years ago the ban on LGBT+ people serving in the British Armed Forces was removed.

    When in 1967 homosexuality was legalised in British society, at the same time new legislation came into effect which forbade gay personnel from serving in the Armed Forces. On 12 January 2000 this law was repealed after the European Court of Human Rights ruled that it violated Article 8 of the Human Rights Act: the right to a private and family life.

    During the ban, anyone discovered to be gay could be subjected to arrest, interrogation, examination, imprisonment, and dismissal. To mark this important anniversary, the RAF Museum has been recording the experiences of those affected by the ban, with help from the military charity for dismissed LGBT+ veterans, Fighting with Pride , and the RAF LGBT+ Freedom Network of currently serving personnel.

    Each month we will share the perspectives of a selection of people who will discuss the impact of the ban and their treatment by the RAF at the time, which had a lasting effect on their lives.

    This month, in our second video, we are sharing a clip from Tracy Footit.

    Tracy joined the RAF Police in 1990 and faced a working environment not entirely welcoming to women. A combination of witnessing sexual harassment and assault and struggles with concealing her sexuality, led to Tracy’s mental health deteriorating.

    In 1993, she was arrested with no evidence and forced to leave the service.

    Tracy was one of over 1,000 people to submit their experience to Lord Etherton’s independent review into the treatment of LGBT veterans submitted in May 2023. In the clip above she talks about the report and the Etherton Ribbon she received.

    Learn more about Tracy’s story and the stories other current and former serving members of the LGBTQIA+ community in the RAF, here.

  • On This Day In History : 4 February 1945

    On This Day In History : 4 February 1945

    This day in 1945, 4 – 11 February: Yalta ‘Big Three’ Conference

    1. 'Big Three' at Yalta: Prime Minister Churchill; President Roosevelt; Premier Stalin. Air Chief Marshal Portal is behind Churchill, talking to First Sea Lord, Admiral of the Fleet Sir Andrew Cunningham. Chief of the Imperial General Staff, General Sir Alan Brooke, is behind Cunningham. (National Archives INF 14/447)‘Big Three’ at Yalta: Prime Minister Churchill; President Roosevelt; Premier Stalin.
    Air Chief Marshal Portal is behind Churchill, talking to First Sea Lord, Admiral of the Fleet Sir Andrew Cunningham. Chief of the Imperial General Staff, General Sir Alan Brooke, is behind Cunningham. (National Archives INF 14/447)

    The conference held in Yalta, Crimea, code-named ‘Argonaut’, opened on 4 February and was the second meeting between the leaders of the major Allied powers during the Second World War: United Kingdom; United States of America; and Soviet Union. And the last time Prime Minister Churchill, President Roosevelt and Premier Stalin would be together.

    By this time, the end of the European war was in sight and the primary objective of Yalta was to plan for the final destruction of German military power and agreeing the immediate post-war world. But against Japan – despite the Allies overwhelming superiority – bitter fighting continued.

    Front lines 1 February 1945. Allied-held territory in pink; recently captured German-held territory in red. (United States Army)On the western European front, the Allies (Britain/Canada and United States) had recovered from the shock of the German Ardennes offensive (‘Battle of the Bulge’) but were still on the west banks of the Rhine – some 300 or more miles from Berlin. Whereas, on the eastern front, Soviet Armies had cleared virtually all of Poland and East Prussia and smashed into Germany on a 300-mile front. The Soviet tide swept over the River Oder into Silesia, surrounded Breslau, and reached within 35 miles of Berlin itself. Stalin taunted Marshals Ivan Koniev and Georgy Zhukov over whether Koniev’s First Ukrainian Front [Front = Soviet Army Group] or Zhukov’s First Belorussian Front would be the first to plant a Red Army flag on Berlin’s Brandenburg Gate.

     

    In the Pacific, Japan’s position was dire: American submarines were imposing a crippling blockade on the vital oil and raw materials their war industries craved. And Boeing B29 Superfortress raids from the airfields in the Marianas were mounting. But still the Japanese fought on – literally suicidally – with Kamikaze attacks. Allied military planners envisaged an invasion of the Japanese main island, Honshu, in 1946 with the fighting potentially dragging on into 1947, with casualty counts on both sides in the millions.

    The principal political outcome from the Yalta Conference was the reinforcement of the concept of European ‘spheres of influence’, first considered at their conference in Tehran in November 1943. Unconditional surrender was demanded of Germany, to be followed by division into zones occupied by four powers: Britain, America, Soviet Union and France. Likewise Berlin would be in four zones, despite being hundreds of miles inside the Soviet Zone, a Cold War flash-point for the next 44 years.

    Poland’s borders were redrawn, transferring some territory in the east to Russia but gaining areas in the west from Germany. The Baltic states of Estonia, Lithuania and Latvia, together with Bessarabia [now Moldova and parts of Ukraine], were incorporated into the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics [USSR, CCCP in Russian].

    The Soviets were to have ‘influence’ in eastern Europe through their respective national governments, permitting some non-Communists to be elected (but this part of the Agreement was ignored and by 1947, all those areas had exclusively Communist governments sympathetic to Moscow). Also the USSR was allowed massive reparations for the damage caused by the German invasion.

    This division of Europe into two politically-opposed ideologies was a very major factor in the long Cold War which was to follow the end of the European war.

    As for Japan, Stalin promised the Soviet Union would declare war on Japan three months after the end of the German war.

    The reference in the published communiqué to ‘unconditional surrender’ dashed the fantasies of Hitler, Göring and other Nazi leaders of negotiating a separate peace with the Western Allies and then German forces fighting alongside them against the Soviets.

    [AUTHOR’S NOTE: of necessity, the above commentary on the highly complex and contentious political elements of the Yalta Agreement has been shortened and simplified. The full text can be studied in the US Library of Congress, together with detailed minutes of every meeting – see Bibliography below.]

    Air Chief Marshal Portal, Chief of Air Staff (IWM TR2Air Chief Marshal Portal, Chief of Air Staff (IWM TR2)

    Churchill was accompanied by the military Chiefs of Staff, with Air Marshal Sir Charles Portal, Chief of the Air Staff, leading the RAF team. This author has been unable to determine the exact size of the British delegation but a later analysis in The National Archives calculated it was not far short of 600, ranging from the then Foreign Secretary, Anthony Eden, Sir Alexander Cadogan, Under-Secretary of State, Foreign Office, through very senior officers – for example, Air Chief Marshal Sir Alfred Earle attended as part of the staff of the War Cabinet Office – to hundreds of more junior officers and other ranks on tasks such as coding, filing, cooks, security etc.

    Many of the coders were WREN and WAAF officers. VVIPs and VIPs flew by Transport Command, usually stopping in Malta. Eden himself flew on York LV 633 Ascalon, leaving Northolt 29 January.

    Log Book of Flight Lieutenant Oswald Morris piloting Foreign Secretary and senior Foreign Office party (RAF Museum X004-4346-002)Log Book of Flight Lieutenant Oswald Morris piloting Foreign Secretary
    and senior Foreign Office party
    (RAF Museum X004-4346-002)

    Whereas a large contingent of lesser ranks went by sea on the SS Franconia, an impressed Cunard liner, which also served as a floating hotel at Sebastopol: only the most senior slept ashore in various villas which had been specially restored for the  occasion, following the devastation caused by the German occupation and subsequent Soviet liberation of the Crimea [at that time all Ukraine was an integral part of the USSR].

    SS FranconiaSS Franconia (above) with boarding pass for 1004391 AC 1 Finney below
    (RAF Museum X004-1435-001)
    Franconia Boarding Card for 1004391 AC 1 Finney (RAF Museum X004-1435-001)

    Sadly, not all the journeys went without incident: on 1st February, 1945, Avro York MW 116, of No. 511 Squadron, en route for Yalta, came down off Lampedusa.(a small island between Malta and Sicily) owing to a navigational error. Eleven crew and passengers were killed, including four members of the War Office staff, four of the Foreign Office and one of Scotland Yard. (See Bibliography for complete list of casualties.)

    Accident card for Avro York MW 116 (RAF MuseumAccident card for Avro York MW 116 (RAF Museum)

    Personal recollections of those attending in any capacity give fascinating insights into  details of both work and social aspects: a luxury cruise liner serving dinners with wine; bright light of Malta where the war was by now far away in northern Italy. And poverty and desolation in Crimea. The BBC’s ‘World War 2 Peoples’ Stories’ series has two worthy of study (listed in Bibliography below).

    Consolidated LB 30 serial AL 504 named 'Commando' with original B 24 style tail. (USAAF via Smithsonian Museum, Washington DC.)Consolidated LB 30 serial AL 504 named ‘Commando’ with original B 24 style tail.
    (USAAF via Smithsonian Museum, Washington DC.)

    Churchill used mainly two aircraft for his personal transport during the Second World War: a Liberator named ‘Commando’ and an Avro York named ‘Ascalon’.Churchill and Portal alighting from original 'Commando' of 24 Squadron RAF at Lyneham, Wiltshire, on their return from the Casablanca Conference January 1943. (IWM CH 8550).

    Churchill and Portal alighting from original ‘Commando’ of 24 Squadron RAF at Lyneham,
    Wiltshire, on their return from the Casablanca Conference January 1943. (IWM CH 8550). 

    The Liberator was a Consolidated LB 30 (the mark type allocated to RAF Liberator bombers, which were different in many details from the B24 bomber provided to the USAAF), RAF serial AL 504. Modifications were made for its VIP role, including a galley and bed for Churchill. It was later further modified by a fuselage extension and replacement of the standard twin-fin tail by a single fin of the type installed on the Privateer, the Consolidated PB4Y-2 variant of the B 24, as used by the US Navy.

    Commando with Privateer-style single fin (IWM CH 14142)Commando with Privateer-style single fin (IWM CH 14142)

    The York was a passenger and freight derivative of the Lancaster, using the same wing and tail (with a third fin, as in the ill-fated Manchester) but with a large box-shaped fuselage; Churchill’s favourite York, named ‘Ascalon’, was serial LV 633.

    Avro York 'Ascalon' arriving at RAF Algiers 5 June 1943 with Churchill and Foreign Secretary Anthony Eden. They were returning to UK from Washington via North Africa. (RAF Museum P018956). Avro York ‘Ascalon’ arriving at RAF Algiers 5 June 1943 with Churchill and Foreign Secretary Anthony Eden. They were returning to UK from Washington via North Africa. (RAF Museum P018956).

    12. Churchill is being met by General Eisenhower (Australian War Museum 4085306)

    Churchill is being met by General Eisenhower (Australian War Museum 4085306)

    On more hazardous routes, Churchill’s aircraft was not alone. An example is his flight from Athens to RAF Aboukir (Alexandria, Egypt) after the conclusion of the Yalta  conference. This time, he used an RAF Transport Command Douglas C 54, with an escort of USAAF Lockheed P 38 Lightnings and an RAF Air Sea Rescue Warwick, complete with parachute-dropped lifeboat designed by the famous yachtsman, Uffa Fox.

    RAF Aboukir magazine

    RAF Aboukir magazine showing Churchill in the door of a C54

    RAF Hassani from the watch-tower: the Lightnings in the foreground escorted Churchill and Roosevelt through the Mediterranean en route to Yalta (RAF Museum PC73/62/41 signed by artist Julius Stafford-Baker)
    RAF Hassani from the watch-tower: the Lightnings in the foreground escorted Churchill and Roosevelt
    through the Mediterranean en route to Yalta (RAF Museum PC73/62/41 signed by artist Julius Stafford-Baker)

    18. Vickers Warwick carrying air-dropped lifeboat (RAF Museum P030
    Vickers Warwick carrying air-dropped lifeboat (RAF Museum P030)

    Bomber crew exercising ASR procedures: transfer from aircraft dinghy to lifeboat dropped by Warwick, circling overhead (RAF Museum P029399)
    Bomber crew exercising ASR procedures: transfer from aircraft dinghy
    to lifeboat dropped
    by Warwick, circling overhead (RAF Museum P029399)

    BIBLIOGRAPHY AND FURTHER READING

    • Joint Statement: US Library of Congress, https://maint.loc.gov/law/help/us-treaties/bevans/m-ust000003-1005.pdf
    • The Final Battle: Cornelius Ryan, William Collins 1966 (and subsequent reprints).
    • Biennial Report of The Chief of Staff of the United States Army July 1, 1943. to the Secretary of War (Atlas of the World Battle Fronts in Semimonthly Phases to August 15 1945)
    • BBC https://www.bbc.co.uk/history/ww2peopleswar/stories/14/a5658014.shtml
    • BBC  https://www.bbc.co.uk/history/ww2peopleswar/stories/12/a4336012.shtml
    • The Inner Circle, a view of war at the top. Joan Bright Astley. Multiple publishers
    • Travels with Churchill: Graham Chandler Air and Space Magazine, Smithsonian Air Museum, Washington DC Museum, Washington DC. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/air-space-magazine/travels-with-churchill-136166507/
    • National Archives
      FCO 12/260  Allied consultation and composition of delegations: practice of wartime leaders
      PREM 4/77/1B Argonaut (Yalta) conference – various
      WO 106/6016 “Jason”/”Fleece” Series of telegrams
      Loss of York MW 116 see https://ww2talk.com/index.php?threads/remembering-today-1-february-1945-avro-york-mw116.36813/